See Jane Get Rich

Financial Goals for Spring 2010

1. Make my 2010 Roth IRA Contribution
2. Roll over 401(k) from my holiday job to a Roth or transfer it to my brokerage
3. Find more affordable car insurance before February 11
4. Obtain a credit report from one of the three agencies
5. Budget/Keep track of my expenses
6. Diversify my investments

Today I visited Scottrade and wrote them a big fat check for $5k for my 2010 Roth IRA contribution.  I like to make my contribution at the very beginning of the year so it can grow the entire year.   

Attempt at Minimizing Trading Fee Damages to Roth Contribution

When I first opened up a Roth IRA I was disheartened by the fees that I got charged everytime I bought something (usually $7).  This is not a huge figure but for my first contribution I made  6 trades so its $7 x 6 trades = $48.00.  That is a lot of money and if you do the math that $48 can grow to $483  in 3o years at 8% and that is a whole lot of money that is basically leaking out of my maximum $5k contribution.  Not cool at all.  I called up Scottrade one day and asked if there was any way the transaction fees could come out of another account so that my $5k contribution would really be a $5k contribution rather than $ 4952 contribution.  The answer was no.  I also wanted to buy some securities that I thought were good buys and I would want to eventually put them in a Roth IRA when I could contribute again next year. 

The employee suggested I open an individual investment account with Scottrade and then transfer the funds when it was time to make my Roth IRA contribution.  I opened an individual account and invested some money.  A few days ago I called Scottrade about how I could transfer my funds in the individual account to the Roth account.  I was told that there was no way I could just transfer those funds since the individual account is taxed and the Roth isn’t taxed.  To use the money in my individual investment account I would have to sell the securities, pay taxes when its time to do so, and transfer the cash to my Roth and then buy the funds again.  So, instead of me spending just $7 to buy a security in my Roth account now I would have to pay three transaction fees.  First $7 charge to buy the stocks for my individual account, $7 to sell them, then transfer the cash to Roth, then $7 to buy the stocks again.  Perfect, instead of $7 it suddenly becomes $21 for the transaction.  I wish I knew who the idiot at Scottrade who advised me to open an individual investment account.   I’ve had basically good experiences with Scottrade so I am not holding it against them.  And now that I think about it, it makes sense that I can’t transfer assets in a taxable account to a non-taxable accountable as simply as I envisioned.  So, I decided to leave my individual account alone to be dealt with another day and wrote the check.

 Tiny Problem with the Roth Contribution

You can only contribute money that you earn to the Roth.  So, in order to contribute $5k in 2010 I need to earn at least $5k in 2010.  There is a tiny problem in that I haven’t earned any money in 2010 and I will likely not earn any money anytime soon because I will be in school until May and then I will be doing bar stuff until the end of July.   So, instead of going on a trip to celebrate graduation I may need to get a job, any job, to get at least $5k in earnings so that I don’t have to withdraw the $5k contribution I just made. 

How do you keep transaction fees from whittling down your actual contribution?  Have you made your 2010 Roth Contribution?